Creatine supplementation spares muscle glycogen during high intensity intermittent exercise in rats
© Roschel et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2010
Received: 18 September 2009
Accepted: 29 January 2010
Published: 29 January 2010
The effects of creatine (CR) supplementation on glycogen content are still debatable. Thus, due to the current lack of clarity, we investigated the effects of CR supplementation on muscle glycogen content after high intensity intermittent exercise in rats.
First, the animals were submitted to a high intensity intermittent maximal swimming exercise protocol to ensure that CR-supplementation was able to delay fatigue (experiment 1). Then, the CR-mediated glycogen sparing effect was examined using a high intensity intermittent sub-maximal exercise test (fixed number of bouts; six bouts of 30-second duration interspersed by two-minute rest interval) (experiment 2). For both experiments, male Wistar rats were given either CR supplementation or placebo (Pl) for 5 days.
As expected, CR-supplemented animals were able to exercise for a significant higher number of bouts than Pl. Experiment 2 revealed a higher gastrocnemius glycogen content for the CR vs. the Pl group (33.59%). Additionally, CR animals presented lower blood lactate concentrations throughout the intermittent exercise bouts compared to Pl. No difference was found between groups in soleus glycogen content.
The major finding of this study is that CR supplementation was able to spare muscle glycogen during a high intensity intermittent exercise in rats.
Creatine (CR) plays an important role in rapid energy provision during muscle contraction involving the transfer of the N-phosphoryl group from phosphorylcreatine (PCR) to ADP to regenerate ATP through a reversible reaction catalyzed by phosphorylcreatine kinase (CK). Moreover, Cr is responsible for energy transfer from mitochondria to cytosol. This function is only possible due to the presence of different PCK isoforms linking the sites of ATP generation (i.e., mitochondria; Mt-PCK) to those of ATP consumption (i.e., skeletal muscle and brain; MM-PCK and BB-PCK, respectively) [1, 2].
Several studies have focused on the ergogenic capacity of CR loading since its efficacy to increase skeletal muscle CR content in humans has been demonstrated . In fact, a growing body of evidence points out the benefits of CR supplementation in short-term high intensity activities (for review, see ), although the mechanisms by which this supplement exerts its effects remains to be fully explored. For instance, the effects of CR supplementation on muscle glycogen content remains to be understood.
Using a one-legged exercise model, it was shown that postexercise muscle glycogen storage can be greater augmented by CR plus carbohydrate supplementation following exercise, as compared to carbohydrate ingestion alone . Lately, these findings have been confirmed by others [6–9]. In addition, it has been demonstrated that carbohydrate supplementation during exhaustive running attenuates the decline in oxidative ATP resynthesis in type I fibres, as indicated by sparing of both PCR and glycogen . However, it is debatable whether CR supplementation is capable of sparing glycogen content during exhaustive exercises. Recently, it was shown that 5-d CR supplementation under conditions of controlled habitual dietary intake had no effect on muscle glycogen content at rest or after continuous endurance exercise . However, it is worth noting that these findings cannot be extrapolated to intermittent exercise, which is knowingly the type of exercise that is the most benefitted by CR supplementation. It is well established that the PCR-CK system plays a crucial role in energy provision during high intensity intermittent exercise. As intramuscular PCR diminishes, the energy provision becomes more reliant on glycolysis (and muscle glycogen) to provide the needed ATP [12–15]. We hypothesized that an increase in PCR content (and in its resynthesis at the rest periods between sets) during intermittent exercise would slow down the PCR decline, followed by less reliance on glycolysis, which would ultimately result in muscle glycogen sparing.
Thus, due to the current lack of clarity, we investigated the effects of CR supplementation on muscle glycogen content after high intensity intermittent exercise in rats. Firstly, we performed an experiment to ensure that CR-supplementation was able to delay fatigue in the adopted exercise protocol. Then, we examined the CR-mediated glycogen sparing effect in intermittent sub-maximal exercise. Assuming that plasma lactate concentration is suggestive of anaerobic pathway flux, we also measured this metabolite throughout the exercise session.
Sixteen male Wistar rats, weighing 218.14 ± 4.76 g were kept on a normal light/dark cycle in a climate-controlled environment for the duration of the study. The rats were maintained in individual cages and were unable to perform spontaneous exercise. All animals were previously submitted to an anaerobic threshold test, which consisted of a progressive overload swimming test for the anaerobic threshold determination, using external weights attached to the animal's chest . Then, the rats were randomly assigned to either the creatine supplementation group (CR n = 8) or the placebo group (Pl n = 8). Principles of laboratory animal care (NIH publication No. 86-23, revised 1985) were followed, as well as specific national laws (n° 9.605/1998). All procedures were approved by the Ethics Committee of the Biomedical Sciences Institute of the University of São Paulo.
Feeding and Supplementation Protocols
Animals were fed ad libitum standard chow (Labina, Ralston Purina do Brasil®) and water. CR supplementation or placebo (water) was administered via gavage. The researchers were blinded to the treatments. Supplementation protocol consisted of two daily dosages of 300 mg each, for 5 days. We had previously found this protocol to be effective in increasing total CR content by approximately 15% in Wistar rats' gastrocnemius muscle (unpublished data). Moreover, the total amount of CR administered in our supplementation protocol is equal to or even more than those amounts used in other studies that also have shown increased total CR at around 25% [17, 18].
All animals underwent a 12 h overnight fasting period before the experimental protocol. The animals were weighed immediately prior to exercise, and then the workload utilized during the experimental protocol was determined, accounting for changes in BW. The animals were then submitted to intermittent high-intensity swimming exercise bouts of 30-second duration. The bouts were performed using a 50% higher external load (attached to the rat's chest) than the one correspondent to the anaerobic threshold. Swimming bouts were interspersed by 2-minute rest intervals. Animals were submitted to as many bouts as possible until fatigue. Fatigue was determined when the rat was submerged for longer than 3 seconds.
Once it was demonstrated that the proposed CR supplementation protocol had effectively improved time-to-exhaustion in an intermittent high intensity exercise, a second experiment was carried out in order to evaluate whether CR supplementation was able to influence glycogen content and blood lactate concentration in a sub-maximal (fixed number of bouts) intermittent high intensity exercise protocol.
Twenty eight male Wistar rats, weighing 217.55 ± 3.54 g were kept on the same conditions as previously described for experiment 1. The procedures for randomization and group assignment (CR - n = 14; Pl - n = 14), the anaerobic threshold test, feeding and supplementation protocols were also identical to those of experiment 1.
All animals underwent a 12 h overnight fasting period before the experimental protocol. They were submitted to 6 bouts of 30-second swimming exercise with supra anaerobic threshold workloads (50% higher than the anaerobic threshold correspondent load). Immediately before testing, animals were weighed and workloads were then calculated. Swimming bouts were interspersed by two-minute rest intervals.
Blood and Tissue Collection
Blood samples (25 μl) were drawn from the tail vein at rest, after a ten-minute unloaded warm-up, and at the end of the two-minute recovery period correspondent to each of the 6 swimming bouts. After the last bout, animals were decapitated and soleus and gastrocnemius muscles were extracted, immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen and kept at -70°C for further glycogen analysis.
Blood and tissue assays
Blood lactate concentration was assessed by an electrochemical technique (Lactate Analyzer - Yellow Springs Instruments 2300 Stat Plus) after stabilization in sodium fluoride (4.7 mM). Glycogen determination followed a previously described protocol . Fifteen animals from the same group of rats from which experimental groups were selected were used for baseline glycogen determinations.
Results are presented as average ± SD. A Proc Mixed Model (SAS®) was performed for blood lactate concentration and glycogen contents . Whenever a significant F-value was obtained, a post-hoc test with a Tukey adjustment was performed for multiple comparison purposes. Correlation between variables was assessed by a Pearson's correlation coefficient Significance level was set at p < 0.05.
Number of bouts to exhaustion
Body weight was increased in CR (229.14 ± 4.38 g) when compared to Pl group after the supplementation period (221.71 ± 4.25 g). Additionally, only CR group showed increased body weight when compared to pre supplementation period (217.55 ± 3.54 g).
The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of CR supplementation on muscle glycogen content after high intensity intermittent exercise in rats. The major finding of this study is that a 5-day CR supplementation spared the gastrocnemius but not soleus glycogen content after a sub-maximal intermittent exercise in rats. The decreased blood lactate concentration in CR-supplemented rats supports the notion that the anaerobic glycolytic system has been less utilized as an energy source during the exercise protocol. The CR-induced glycogen sparing might partially explain the improved performance often observed in intermittent exercises as a consequence of this supplement. The absence of significant change in soleus glycogen content is not surprising and reflects the rather low CR and glycogen content in type I vs. type II fibers , minimizing the impact of our intervention in the predominantly oxidative soleus muscle.
The possible role of CR supplementation on muscle glycogen modulation has been previously pointed out . The authors demonstrated that postexercise muscle glycogen storage can be augmented by CR and carbohydrate supplementation following exercise compared with carbohydrate ingestion alone. Thereafter, it has been shown that CR-supplemented subjects, during a phase of rehabilitation from immobilization-induced muscle atrophy, had larger muscle glycogen content when compared with non-supplemented subjects (650 versus 520 mmol/kg dry weight) . Accordingly, an 18% increase in muscle glycogen content has been reported as a result of 5 days of concomitant CR and carbohydrate supplementation compared with placebo ingestion . It has been shown that performing a glycogen loading protocol (exhaustive exercise followed by a high carbohydrate diet for 3 days) after CR loading resulted in a 10% greater glycogen content when compared to a glycogen loading before CR loading protocol . In light of these findings, it has been speculated that CR supplementation could beneficially affect performance by modulating pre-exercise muscle glycogen content. Furthermore, it has been speculated that CR loading could also affect performance during exercise by increasing PCR content and consequently decreasing the reliance on glycolysis and muscle glycogen [23, 24].
However, no effect of a 5-day CR supplementation on muscle glycogen content has been reported in healthy volunteers either at rest or after continuous endurance exercise to exhaustion . This prompted the investigators to conclude that CR per se is not sufficient to alter muscle glycogen content. In the current trial, we noted greater glycogen content in the gastrocnemius muscle following exercise in the 5-day CR supplemented rats, indicating that CR loading is capable of sparing glycogen content throughout an intermittent exercise bout. Some methodological differences between the studies may explain the dissonant findings.
First, the findings obtained with continuous endurance exercise  cannot be extended to intermittent exercise. In the latter, it is well established that the ergogenic effect of CR is more pronounced. Since ATP synthesis rate from the creatine kinase reaction with CR loading is reduced dramatically in the first few seconds, rest intervals are crucial to allow adequate (though not complete) aerobic-dependent PCR resynthesis (for details, see ). In fact, CR supplementation plays a major role in energy provision during short-duration intermittent exercise; in contrast, energy necessary to maintain long-duration endurance exercise occurs predominantly via aerobic and anaerobic pathways in detriment to the PCR-CR system. In light of this, it is reasonable to speculate that during intermittent exercise, increased muscle PCR content could spare glycogen, serving as an immediate energy source in the myocyte. Accordingly, the lower blood lactate concentration seen in CR group may be a result of a reduced flux through the anaerobic glycolytic pathway or even a shift in glucose metabolism towards oxidation as previously seen in L6 rat skeletal muscle cell . This notion is further supported by the negative relationship between blood lactate concentration and muscle glycogen content observed in the present study. Alternatively, since plasma lactate concentration represents the net result of overall lactate production and utilization by the tissues, it is possible that an increase in tissue lactate utilization could have also accounted for the lower plasma lactate concentration observed in the CR group.
Second, it is not possible to rule out that the discordant findings are a result of different experimental models investigated. Previous studies have demonstrated major differences between species regarding CR transport, bioavailability, metabolism, uptake and physiological response, as previously pinpointed by others [26, 27]. For instance, a rapid and nearly complete gastrointestinal absorption of CR has been shown in humans , contrasting with the lack of absorption in an herbivorous animal such as the horse. In addition, an elegant study  highlighted the species-and tissue-specific response to CR intake. The authors demonstrated that CR administration can induce chronic hepatitis in mice, but not in rats, suggesting large variance even between close species. Furthermore, in contrast to humans, muscle glycogen content may have little effect on endurance during submaximal exercise in mice , although, the authors emphasize that muscle glycogen might have a greater impact on performance under anaerobic muscular activity, as in the case of the present study. Therefore, taking into account the species-specific differences, the current findings should be further validated and cannot be fully extrapolated to humans at this point.
Although we did not measure muscle CR content, we believe that the adopted supplementation regime has efficiently increased intramuscular CR based on previous data from our laboratory and the results of others that have used similar protocols [17, 18]. Moreover, the rapid increase in body weight observed only in CR group suggests that creatine uptake occurred since water retention is a well documented effect of CR supplementation . However, we acknowledge that the lack of muscle CR assessment could be viewed as a limitation of the present study. Still, one may argue that the lack of resting glycogen measurement after CR supplementation could be considered a factor in this study because it would preclude dissociating the effect of CR on glycogen content during exercise from that at rest. However, accumulative evidence indicates that CR supplementation, in the absence of prior exercise, does not increase muscle glycogen storage . Recently, convincing findings that dietary CR supplementation does not influence resting muscle glycogen content in recreationally active volunteers has been provided, supporting the hypothesis that dietary CR-associated increases in muscle glycogen content are a result of an interaction between dietary supplementation and other mediators of muscle glucose transport, such as muscle contraction . Accordingly, we also showed that CR supplementation (the same protocol used in the current study) does not increase glycogen content in sedentary Wistar rats . Therefore, the fact that the rats were non-exercised in the present study allows assuming that the sparing effects of CR on glycogen content occurred during exercise. Another possible debatable point is the lack of a control group receiving isonitrogenous and isoenergetic diet. However, this is unlikely to play a role in the results, since several studies have shown creatine-induced glycogen accretion even when compared with a carbohydrate supplemented group [6–9]. Finally, it is worth emphasizing that rats were submitted to 12-h fasting before exercise, and muscle glycogen contents were rather lower than those reported by others [30–34]. Nonetheless, the rats were submitted to a normal light/dark cycle. Considering that rats usually feed during dark and sleep during light, the 12 h-food restriction during dark cycle prior to the exercise reflects a "real" fasting closer to 24 hours and not 12 hours. For this reason, we can assume that the longer than usual fasting period in this study can partially explain the low muscle glycogen observed. Thus, the current findings cannot be extrapolated to a "glycogen loaded" condition (i.e., post absorptive state or after carbohydrate supplementation). However, considering that individuals engaged in intermittent sport modalities achieve partial glycogen depletion in the closing minutes of a competition or training session, the findings of this study still have importance for those desiring to enhance sport performance.
We demonstrated that CR supplementation is able to spare gastrocnemius glycogen content and reduce blood lactate concentration in rats submitted to intermittent high intensity exercise. If confirmed by human studies, CR-induced glycogen sparing could be another mechanism to explain the ergogenic effect of CR supplementation in intermittent exercise.
The authors wish to thanks Mr. James Bambino for proofreading the manuscript. This study was supported by Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo - FAPESP (99/07678-3).
- Gualano B, Novaes RB, Artioli GG, Freire TO, Coelho DF, Scagliusi FB, Rogeri PS, Roschel H, Ugrinowitsch C, Lancha AH: Effects of creatine supplementation on glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity in sedentary healthy males undergoing aerobic training. Amino Acids. 2008, 34: 245-250. 10.1007/s00726-007-0508-1.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Greenhaff PL: The creatine-phosphocreatine system: there's more than one song in its repertoire. J Physiol. 2001, 537: 657-10.1113/jphysiol.2001.013478.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Harris RC, Soderlund K, Hultman E: Elevation of creatine in resting and exercised muscle of normal subjects by creatine supplementation. Clin Sci (Lond). 1992, 83: 367-374.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Terjung RL, Clarkson P, Eichner ER, Greenhaff PL, Hespel PJ, Israel RG, Kraemer WJ, Meyer RA, Spriet LL, Tarnopolsky MA, Wagenmakers AJ, Williams MH: American College of Sports Medicine roundtable. The physiological and health effects of oral creatine supplementation. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000, 32: 706-717. 10.1097/00005768-200003000-00024.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Robinson TM, Sewell DA, Hultman E, Greenhaff PL: Role of submaximal exercise in promoting creatine and glycogen accumulation in human skeletal muscle. J Appl Physiol. 1999, 87: 598-604.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nelson AG, Arnall DA, Kokkonen J, Day R, Evans J: Muscle glycogen supercompensation is enhanced by prior creatine supplementation. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2001, 33: 1096-1100.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Derave W, Eijnde BO, Verbessem P, Ramaekers M, Van Leemputte M, Richter EA, Hespel P: Combined creatine and protein supplementation in conjunction with resistance training promotes muscle GLUT-4 content and glucose tolerance in humans. J Appl Physiol. 2003, 94: 1910-1916.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- van Loon LJ, Murphy R, Oosterlaar AM, Cameron-Smith D, Hargreaves M, Wagenmakers AJ, Snow R: Creatine supplementation increases glycogen storage but not GLUT-4 expression in human skeletal muscle. Clin Sci (Lond). 2004, 106: 99-106. 10.1042/CS20030116.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cribb PJ, Hayes A: Effects of supplement timing and resistance exercise on skeletal muscle hypertrophy. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2006, 38: 1918-1925. 10.1249/01.mss.0000233790.08788.3e.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tsintzas K, Williams C, Constantin-Teodosiu D, Hultman E, Boobis L, Clarys P, Greenhaff P: Phosphocreatine degradation in type I and type II muscle fibres during submaximal exercise in man: effect of carbohydrate ingestion. J Physiol. 2001, 537: 305-311. 10.1111/j.1469-7793.2001.0305k.x.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sewell DA, Robinson TM, Greenhaff PL: Creatine supplementation does not affect human skeletal muscle glycogen content in the absence of prior exercise. J Appl Physiol. 2008, 104: 508-512. 10.1152/japplphysiol.00787.2007.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bogdanis GC, Nevill ME, Boobis LH, Lakomy HK: Contribution of phosphocreatine and aerobic metabolism to energy supply during repeated sprint exercise. J Appl Physiol. 1996, 80: 876-884.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gaitanos GC, Williams C, Boobis LH, Brooks S: Human muscle metabolism during intermittent maximal exercise. J Appl Physiol. 1993, 75: 712-719.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hargreaves M, McKenna MJ, Jenkins DG, Warmington SA, Li JL, Snow RJ, Febbraio MA: Muscle metabolites and performance during high-intensity, intermittent exercise. J Appl Physiol. 1998, 84: 1687-1691.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gualano B, Artioli GG, Poortmans JR, Lancha Junior AH: Exploring the therapeutic role of creatine supplementation. Amino Acids. 2009Google Scholar
- Marquezi ML, Roschel HA, dos Santa Costa A, Sawada LA, Lancha AH: Effect of aspartate and asparagine supplementation on fatigue determinants in intense exercise. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2003, 13: 65-75.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gallo M, Gordon T, Syrotuik D, Shu Y, Tyreman N, MacLean I, Kenwell Z, Putman CT: Effects of long-term creatine feeding and running on isometric functional measures and myosin heavy chain content of rat skeletal muscles. Pflugers Arch. 2006, 452: 744-755. 10.1007/s00424-006-0079-0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Op't Eijnde B, Jijakli H, Hespel P, Malaisse WJ: Creatine supplementation increases soleus muscle creatine content and lowers the insulinogenic index in an animal model of inherited type 2 diabetes. Int J Mol Med. 2006, 17: 1077-1084.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Passonneau JV, Lowry OH: Enzymatic Analysis: A Practical Guide. 1993, New Jersey: Human PressView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ugrinowitsch C, Fellingham GW, Ricard MD: Limitations of Ordinary Least Squares Models in Analyzing Repeated Measures Data. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2004, 36: 2144-2148. 10.1249/01.MSS.0000147580.40591.75.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Greenhaff PL, Bodin K, Soderlund K, Hultman E: Effect of oral creatine supplementation on skeletal muscle phosphocreatine resynthesis. Am J Physiol. 1994, 266: E725-730.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Op 't Eijnde B, Richter EA, Henquin JC, Kiens B, Hespel P: Effect of creatine supplementation on creatine and glycogen content in rat skeletal muscle. Acta Physiol Scand. 2001, 171: 169-176. 10.1046/j.1365-201x.2001.00786.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brannon TA, Adams GR, Conniff CL, Baldwin KM: Effects of creatine loading and training on running performance and biochemical properties of rat skeletal muscle. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1997, 29: 489-495.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yquel RJ, Arsac LM, Thiaudiere E, Canioni P, Manier G: Effect of creatine supplementation on phosphocreatine resynthesis, inorganic phosphate accumulation and pH during intermittent maximal exercise. J Sports Sci. 2002, 20: 427-437. 10.1080/026404102317366681.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ceddia RB, Sweeney G: Creatine supplementation increases glucose oxidation and AMPK phosphorylation and reduces lactate production in L6 rat skeletal muscle cells. J Physiol. 2004, 555: 409-421. 10.1113/jphysiol.2003.056291.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sewell DA, Harris RC: Effect of creatine supplementation in the thoroughbred horse. Equine Vet J. 1995, 18: 239-242.Google Scholar
- Tarnopolsky MA, Bourgeois JM, Snow R, Keys S, Roy BD, Kwiecien JM, Turnbull J: Histological assessment of intermediate- and long-term creatine monohydrate supplementation in mice and rats. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol. 2003, 285: R762-769.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pederson BA, Cope CR, Schroeder JM, Smith MW, Irimia JM, Thurberg BL, DePaoli-Roach AA, Roach PJ: Exercise capacity of mice genetically lacking muscle glycogen synthase: in mice, muscle glycogen is not essential for exercise. J Biol Chem. 2005, 280: 17260-17265. 10.1074/jbc.M410448200.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Freire TO, Gualano B, Leme MD, Polacow VO, Lancha Junior AH: Effects of creatine supplementation on glucose uptake in rats submitted to exercise training. Braz J Sports Med. 2008, 14: 431-435.Google Scholar
- Armstrong RB, Saubert CWt, Sembrowich WL, Shepherd RE, Gollnick PD: Glycogen depletion in rat skeletal muscle fibers at different intensities and durations of exercise. Pflugers Arch. 1974, 352: 243-256. 10.1007/BF00590489.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Clark JH, Conlee RK: Muscle and liver glycogen content: diurnal variation and endurance. J Appl Physiol. 1979, 47: 425-428.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Conlee RK, Rennie MJ, Winder WW: Skeletal muscle glycogen content: diurnal variation and effects of fasting. Am J Physiol. 1976, 231: 614-618.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Conlee RK, McLane JA, Rennie MJ, Winder WW, Holloszy JO: Reversal of phosphorylase activation in muscle despite continued contractile activity. Am J Physiol. 1979, 237: R291-296.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hickson RC, Rennie MJ, Conlee RK, Winder WW, Holloszy JO: Effects of increased plasma fatty acids on glycogen utilization and endurance. J Appl Physiol. 1977, 43: 829-833.PubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.